Peanut Butter Cups: Week 6 of 12 Weeks of Christmas Treats

By Coleen

It’s Thursday, and time for another installment of 12 Weeks of Christmas Treats, hosted by Meal Planning Magic. If you’re a blogger, it’s never too late to sign up! Head on over and fill out the form.

One of my favorite childhood memories is making Christmas “chocolates” with my grandmother. She had dozens of plastic molds, and we would melt bags and bags of green, red, white, and chocolate candy melts. We’d fill the molds — wreaths, stockings, trees, reindeer, mistletoe, stars, snowmen, etc. — harden them in the fridge, then pop them out of the molds.

Some were wrapped in candy boxes and given as gifts to her friends, neighbors, and co-workers. Others were set aside and put in candy dishes during the holiday season.

I looked forward to making those candies with her every year. We continued to do it together even into my adulthood, until she got sick and passed in 2006. So, these Christmas treats are in memory of her. I’ve replaced the chocolate candy melts with a blend of real chocolate, and added some festive decorations on top. I also discovered that special candy cup molds aren’t necessary — these cups can be made in mini muffin pans!

Homemade Peanut Butter Cups

Serves 36 candy cups
Meal type Dessert
Misc Child Friendly, Freezable
Occasion Christmas
Website Joy of Baking


  • 9oz milk chocolate, chopped
  • 1 tablespoon vegetable shortening
  • ½ cup creamy peanut butter
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter at room temperature
  • Pinch ofsalt
  • ½ cup confectioners sugar
  • 9oz semi-sweet chocolate, chopped


  • Red and green nonpareils
  • Red candy melts


Equipment needed

    Mini muffin tins
    Mini paper liners (optional)


Step 1
Bring about an inch of water in a large saucepan to a boil. Lower the heat, and bring the water to a simmer. Place the chopped chocolate in a clean, dry bowl and set it over (but not touching) the simmering water. Stir often until melted.
Step 2
While chocolate is melting, place the peanut butter, butter, and the salt in a microwave-safe bowl. Heat for one minute on full power, until the peanut butter is soft, but not melted. Remove from the microwave, add the confectioners’ sugar, and stir until smooth.
Step 3
If using, place mini paper liners in each well of a mini muffin pan. Place one teaspoonful of melted chocolate in the bottom of each muffin well. When each is filled, gently shake the pan and tap it on the counter to level the chocolate and remove air bubbles.
Step 4
Place a teaspoonful of the peanut butter mixture in each well, then top with another teaspoonful of chocolate. Add another half-teaspoonful of chocolate if necessary, to completely cover the peanut butter. Shake the pan gently again, and tap to remove air bubbles. If using sprinkles or nonpareils, sprinkle a few over the candy cups now. Or, melt a few red candy melts in the microwave, scrape into a parchment paper bag, and pipe bows onto the top of each cup.
Step 5
Refrigerate the entire muffin pan until the chocolate is set. If you didn’t use mini paper liners (which will allow the cups to slide ride out), let pan sit at room temperature for about 5 to 10 minutes so the chocolate can soften, then turn the pan over and rap it against the edge of a counter until the candy cups fall out.

Check out what treats the other participants are baking! Click on the photos below.


  1. Love these! My great aunt used to send us homemade candies every Christmas, and the peanut butter ones were always my favorite. Is there a reason you use a combination of milk and semisweet chocolate?

    • Personal preference, really. I happen to like the way it tastes. I should have mentioned in the post that you can use any flavor of chocolate (milk, semisweet, bittersweet, milk, etc.) or combination that you prefer.

  2. My husband would love these! He is a huge fan of peanut butter cups. I’m glad you were able to keep your grandmother’s spirit alive by making these.

  3. I think I’m going to need to increase my workouts this year-I could probably eat a whole batch of these by myself! They look amazing!

  4. Peanut butter cups are my all time favorite. You have inspired me to try making my own!

  5. Definitely one of my favorites!

  6. Mmmm dellicious, pinnend it!

    Marina #3

  7. How sweet that you have the memories with your grandmother. She would be proud that you’re continuing the tradition with such delicious treats.


  1. […] the last row, top left is homemade peanut butter cups, treats that I made with my grandmother when I was a […]

Speak Your Mind